“Only half a kilo today, sir?” asked the vegetable vendor.
“Yes,” I said. “The price has gone up.”
“So has the economy,” he said. “I heard it on the news.”
“Then give me the other half on credit,” I said. “I’ll pay you when the growth reaches my pocket.”
He handed me the half kilo.
When the government says the economy has grown by around seven per cent, it means the country is producing more goods and services than before. That is welcome. But if your pay rises a little and your rent, groceries and school fees rise by more, you have less money left at the end of the month. The economy can grow while your shopping bag gets lighter. My vegetable vendor and I understood that without calling in an economist.
Still, I’m glad the Finance Minister has heard from economists. One question worth asking is how to turn that growth into jobs. The government can keep building roads, railways and ports, making it cheaper for businesses to get their goods to customers. But companies also have to put their own money into factories, machines and workers. And before they do that, they need to believe enough people can afford to buy what they make.
I thought of a young graduate going for his first interview. “Have you any experience?” asks the manager. “No, sir. That’s why I’m here.” The manager tells him to come back when he has some. The young man goes home to parents who have spent years paying for his education. What they want to hear now is that somebody is willing to give him a start.
A small workshop owner might be just the person to do it. Suppose he has enough orders to hire two apprentices. A large customer owes him money, and the bank wants more paperwork before it will lend him enough to buy materials for his next order. If the customer pays on time and the loan comes through, he can hire. Simpler tax rules would give him a little more time to run the workshop, too. For those two apprentices, that is what helping small businesses would mean.
The same question applies when we give companies money to manufacture in India. If a factory puts together a product from imported parts, it creates some work here. If it also buys parts from Indian suppliers, the work spreads to other factories and workshops. At the opening ceremony, I’d like someone to ask how many of those workshops got an order. They can cut the ribbon afterwards.
On my way home, my wife called. “Did you get a kilo of tomatoes? We have guests tonight.”
I went back to the vendor. “Give me the other half,” I said.
“Has the growth reached you already, sir?”
“No,” I said, taking out my wallet. “My wife says I’m welcome to call the Finance Minister to explain seven per cent growth to our guests. But I think she’s busy, trying to explain the same to her husband…!”
———————————-
Become an author… Click here
Click Here: Pick up my latest book…’One Note at A Time’
——————————-
Would love to hear from you in the COMMENTS section below…and IF YOU WANT TO RECEIVE BOB’S BANTER EVERYDAY, PLEASE SEND YOUR NAME AND WHATSAPP PHONE NO TO [email protected]



Robert Clements is a newspaper columnist and writes a daily column, which has graced the pages of over 60 newspapers and magazines, from a daily column in the Khaleej Times, Dubai, the Morning Star, London, and in nearly every state in India, from The Statesman in Kolkata, to the Kashmir Times in Kashmir to the Trinity Mirror in Chennai.
Seven percent or eight percent make no sense to consumers who have no purchasing power. The growth is meant to make rich richer and to fill pockets of poor. The GST and demonetisation are the cause of closing down of small scale industries. GST makes the government rich and the consumers buying power shrinks. The growth is measured by GST collection which is wrong. One man’s gain is another’s loss. There can not be an egalitarian society till every citizen gets his due.