I think Indian Railways should immediately introduce one more announcement on Mumbai’s suburban trains. “Dear passengers, please avoid asking anybody to close the train door. You may lose your life.”
Absurd?
Not anymore.
There was a time when boarding a Mumbai local meant risking a squashed foot, a torn shirt, or discovering that somebody else’s elbow had permanently taken up residence in your ribs. You came home exhausted, but alive.
Now, according to reports, one fellow passenger asking to shut the door because rain was blowing into the compartment was allegedly stabbed to death.
Again.
And again.
And again.
When did we become like this?
I don’t think this is about trains. Nor is it about first class compartments. Nor is it about overcrowding.
This is about rage. Pure, unadulterated rage. The kind that sits inside people like a pressure cooker with the whistle ready to blow off.
It needs only the smallest spark.
“Move a little.”
“Horn mat bajao.”
“Stand in the queue.”
“Close the door.”
Boom.
The explosion begins.
It wasn’t always like this.
There was a time when fellow passengers shared newspapers, exchanged jokes and even held babies while tired mothers caught a little sleep. If someone boarded with heavy luggage, ten hands reached out to help. Somebody would even shout, “Arre bhai, make a little space.”
Today, we seem ready to make space only for anger.
Ironically, this has happened at a time when our cities have never looked better.
The Metro glides gracefully overhead. The Coastal Road hugs the sea. Expressways slice through mountains. Bridges leap across creeks.
Every week there seems to be another ribbon cutting ceremony.
Wonderful. I genuinely applaud all of it.
But somewhere while we were laying concrete, we lay the foundation for hate.
While building roads, we built division.
While constructing stations, we demolished love.
A nation is not held together by cement. It is held together by compassion.
That is where I believe this government has failed.
Not because it has failed to build. Oh yes, it has built magnificently.
It has failed because, year after year, we have been encouraged to live in an atmosphere where outrage is celebrated, opponents demonised, abuse applauded and division is rewarded.
Every fiery speech, every poisonous slogan, every attempt to make one Indian hate another plants a seed of hate.
You cannot spend years sowing suspicion, anger and hatred among people, then stand back in horror when one day those seeds bear fruit in the blood stained compartment of a Mumbai local.
Yes, give this government full credit for its roads, bridges, Metros and trains.
But when it comes to the rage that is poisoning the hearts travelling in them, I believe this government must bear the blame.
Because when you spend years sowing hate, you should never be surprised when blood soaks a Mumbai local…!
———————————–
Become an author… Click here
————————————-
Would love to hear from you in the COMMENTS section below…and IF YOU WANT TO RECEIVE BOB’S BANTER EVERYDAY, PLEASE SEND YOUR NAME AND WHATSAPP PHONE NO TO [email protected]
————————————————–



Robert Clements is a newspaper columnist and writes a daily column, which has graced the pages of over 60 newspapers and magazines, from a daily column in the Khaleej Times, Dubai, the Morning Star, London, and in nearly every state in India, from The Statesman in Kolkata, to the Kashmir Times in Kashmir to the Trinity Mirror in Chennai.
Hate begets hate. Humility generates humility. These are times when truth is twisted to untruth and vice versa. There are very few places where two men see eye to eye.
Loved the flow of your narration.
Lovely piece. Yes hate has absolutely consumed us. From road rage cases. More alarming was such a huge knife being carried!! In the metro here in Blr its not allowed
Intolerance ! That is what it is. The unwillingness or refusal to accept views, beliefs or behavior that differ from one’s own. Tolerance doesn’t mean you approve of every belief. You can strongly disagree with an idea while still treating the person with dignity. That balance is what, should keep plural societies like in India, working .
Hate has no religion and no face. But that is not the all, the frustration of bearing the burden of the family, the huge divide between the haves and the don’t haves it all demands for an outlet. It’s not the first not is it the last. The public don’t get involved to help stop this because they are scared and worried about their own families
So frightening to know that a stranger can kill you for no real reason. Why are we people who are full of hate & anger in a country that had Mahatma Gandhi as a beacon? Beliefs of Non violence & satyagraha all lost
How very terrible that such a thing could happen. What a tragedy. Why is there so much hatred for each other? People who are taught to hate others take the licence to kill in broad daylight in a crowded train. What is happening to this country? May God comfort that poor bereaved family.
Addressing mental health has to be taken up on top priority in today’s times. Physical wounds are visible, but mental-emotional are not, hence they stay suppressed and fester. And then surface maliciously at the slightest trigger.
I once heard a preacher tell us.
“To hate is like drinking poison, hoping that your enemy dies.”
Super post Bob!! I bet Everyone reading this echoes the same…
Hate, Volatile, Mercurial temperaments, Intolerance, illiteracy and Division have replaced cuss words and profanity…since the last 12 years…and, humanity will soon be extinct from people’s hearts… God forbid…